Choosing the Best Wet Food for Your Dog
In this Springtime Dog Health Spotlight, we examine each of the four major dog feeding styles: dry, wet, raw, and homemade. We'll go over the basics for each style, the pros/cons, best practices, and things to avoid.
Wet Dog Food: How It's Made
Wet or canned dog food is made by mixing animal meat, plant matter, vitamins, and other ingredients into a processed, pre-cooked stew or loaf, which is then packed into a sanitized container (e.g., a can). Typically, the dog food mixture is then re-cooked at a high temperature and pressure while in the sealed container to destroy any contaminants. Because of this level of processing, some dog owners are asking: Is wet dog food bad for dogs? The simplest answer is: It depends.
Wet Dog Food Summary
Pros of Wet Dog Food:
- Typically contains more meat protein than dry/kibble
- Fewer carbs mean reduced potential for weight gain
- Air-tight cans reduce the need for synthetic preservatives
- Helps keep dogs hydrated, especially dogs who don't get enough water
- Entices eating in dogs with teeth issues, or diminished sense of smell or appetite
Cons of Wet Dog Food:
- Spoils easily
- More expensive than kibble (you pay for water content)
- Bulky to store
- Potential health risk from foods in cans with BPA lining
- Processing often destroys nutrients
- Does not provide live factors for wide spectrum nutrition
Choosing a Good Wet Dog Food
As with dry food, whether wet dog food is good for dogs comes down to the quality of a wet dog food, particularly on the type and amount of meat protein it contains (and the unhealthy additives it does NOT contain). Generally, wet dog foods contain more protein, and the canning process itself removes the need for preservatives and other undesirable additives. This means, however, that wet dog food begins to spoil after it is opened, so it cannot be left out for long periods. Unlike dry dog foods, wet dog foods cannot be free-fed to your dog, but that practice is generally frowned upon anyway, as it can lead to obesity.
Hallmarks of a Good Wet Dog Food
The more quality, digestible animal protein it contains, the better it is. The list of ingredients is going to be a dog owner's best tool in determining the quality of a wet dog food. The contents of the food will be listed in order from the ingredient with the highest percentage of the overall weight, down to the lowest. Wet dog foods contain a lot of moisture, so it is not a deal-breaker to find water as the first ingredient. When you factor out the water, wet dog foods still have about 50% more protein per serving on average than dry offerings.
A meat ingredient with a name you recognize (e.g., beef, lamb, etc.) should be within the first three ingredients, if not the first. Also, you want that main ingredient to be a single-named meat (e.g., "turkey" rather than "turkey byproduct"). Animal byproducts and animal meals are the super-cooked bones and other low-grade tissues of the animal carcass, so their nutritional value is difficult to discern, and it might be best to assume zero (although an animal meal is better than a byproduct, by definition). Indigestible proteins found in these meals/byproducts inflate the protein percentage, making the Guaranteed Analysis dubious, if not worthless. Organ meat is an appropriate ingredient in dog food, as dogs need nutrients they can only get from organ meat; however, you want to see the specific animal the organ came from (e.g., "turkey liver," rather than just "liver"). It is not recommended to consistently feed a diet of primarily organ meat without variety. It is always best to feed a mixture of proteins and organ meats, and canned food diets are no exception.
Fruits, vegetables, and grains are commonly included in wet dog food recipes, but they can be used as fillers to pad its protein content stats. Dogs' internal organs have to work harder to absorb nutrition from plant sources, especially corn and soy. When you combine the unwanted carbohydrate content and poorly absorbed protein in vegetable sources, you create a situation where dogs need to overeat to get the nutrients they need, resulting in weight gain and obesity for many dogs. By the way, some products include vegetables in miniscule amounts just to make the products seem healthier.
Red Flags of a Bad Wet Dog Food
Because they are cooked and contained in airtight cans, dog foods generally don't require preservatives, which can be unhealthy for dogs. If your wet dog food includes preservatives, that's not a good sign. It certainly calls into question the freshness of the meat before it was canned. The canning process isn't without health concerns, though. Many cans are lined with BPA (Bisphenol A), which has been linked to health issues in humans and pets.
Let's talk about additives. Wet dog foods are typically high in muscle meat protein, so they look, smell, and taste like they should, and dogs respond to that. If the canned dog food in question contains artificial sweeteners, flavors, or coloring, you have to wonder what kind of meat they are using that would require so much help. Binders, such as wheat gluten, help slices and chunks of meat retain their shape during processing, but they can also be used to help inferior ingredients form clumps that imitate real meat chunks. Natural gums (e.g., guar gum) are also used as binders in this capacity.
For a list of ingredients that you might want to avoid in your dog food, check out this handy list.
It should be noted that the process by which commercial wet dog food is cooked could be destroying the nutritional quality of otherwise healthy ingredients. This is why many commercial dog foods include added vitamins and minerals that are needed by dogs. The term "complete and balanced" on the dog food packaging means that the nutritional profile should meet the U.S. government's minimum standards for a dog's nutritional needs. Even when it meets this standard, commercial dog foods lack essential nutrients, including live factors that dogs would get from a more natural food source, but these nutrients can and should be supplemented at feeding times.
To learn more about another feeding style, click one of the links below...Dry Dog Food Raw Dog Food Homemade Dog Food
< 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | >
No matter which feeding style you prefer, you can replicate the diet nature intended with these natural supplements for dogs:
Don't just take our word for it! Read what our customers say about their own experiences with Springtime products.
"...I have weaned her off of ALL of her medications..."
I just want to say Thanks! My 11-year-old, 8-lb. Toy Rat Terrier, Annabelle, was on Gabapentin, Tramadol and Metacam for a pinched nerve in her back. She would barely walk, even in the house. I found out about Longevity when searching for alternative methods for handling chronic pain. Now, 2 months later, I have weaned her off of ALL of her medications and give her Longevity twice a day. She is back to her normal self and back to her long walks around the neighborhood. She is running around, playing fetch, and acts younger than ever. Her coat looks beautiful, and her grass allergies are not as severe this year either. I swear your product is a miracle cure. I can't thank you enough for giving our Annabelle her life back.
With best regards,
Heidi Petras, Maryland